One problem that people rarely think about when sending cold emails is whether they set up their infrastructure the right way. Most cold email campaigns fail because the prospect never saw the email. If your emails land in spam or bounce, your prospect never sees them. The fix is investing in your cold email infrastructure.
I currently orchestrate cold email sending using 250+ mailboxes. This little guide is based on what I’ve learned, and it will help you set up your cold email infrastructure properly for any scale.
What Is Cold Email Infrastructure?
Your cold email infrastructure has one job: make sure your emails reach your prospects’ inboxes. Setting it up is a five-step process:
Domains: use dedicated, separate domains that you only use for outreach, and redirect them to your primary domain
Mailboxes: the mailboxes you use, like broiscooked@orange.co, which send and receive emails
DNS authentication: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records that prove your emails are legitimate
Warmup: build sender reputation for your domain using the mailboxes before you scale volume
Sending/sequencing tool and monitoring: the software that sends and monitors your emails
Buy Secondary Domains (Don’t Use Your Main Domain)
Never send cold outreach from your primary domain. A spam report on your primary domain can hurt the deliverability of your real customer emails, invoices, and other replies. Buy separate lookalike domains dedicated to outreach.
How to choose sending domains
If your primary domain is acme.com, you can use close variations of your brand, like tryacme.com, getacme.com, and acmehq.com. Use a .com where possible, since it generally looks more trustworthy than other TLDs. Make sure the domain redirects to your main website; prospects might do their own research and then book a demo or sign up without even replying to your email.
How many domains do you need?
It depends on your sending volume. A common rule of thumb is three mailboxes per domain, and the number of domains scales with how many emails you want to send per day (20 per mailbox is my limit, which I explain in a later section). I prefer 2 mailboxes per domain. Spreading mailboxes across more domains reduces risk: if one domain gets a spam problem, it doesn’t affect all of the mailboxes I use. Also, deliverability improves as your domain ages and lands more emails in the inbox, so I’d rather not have all my eggs in one basket.
If you’re just starting out and testing whether cold email works as a channel for you, you can start with 3 to 5 domains and 2 mailboxes per domain. If this channel starts working for you, buy a few reserve domains so that you’ll have warmed-up domains and mailboxes as insurance if any of your current domains get spam-blocked.
Set Up Your Mailboxes
You have two options. You can set up Google or Microsoft mailbox accounts yourself, which can be time-consuming, and you also don’t want to share the same SMTP or sending IP that your primary domain uses, so it’s best to isolate these mailboxes in a different Google Workspace. Or, to make things easy, you can use mailbox providers like Primeforge or InboxKit; there are a lot of providers out there.
You can use a mix of Google and Microsoft mailboxes. I’ve found that Google mailboxes have better deliverability to other Google inboxes, and the same is true for Microsoft to Microsoft. Most sending tools (that is, email sequencers) have this option built in, probably labeled ESP matching.
Use a real sender name and email address; avoid generic addresses like sales@acme.com or info@acme.com. Add a profile photo and an email signature.
Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC
This is the core of your cold email infrastructure. These three DNS records tell inbox providers that your email really comes from you and hasn’t been spoofed. I’m not going into the details of what those records are in this post, but make sure you’ve set them up if you’re configuring mailboxes yourself. If you’re using a mailbox provider, they’ll take care of this for you.
One side note: when you’re using a mailbox provider, make sure you get access to the full DNS for all the domains you purchase through the provider. This helps you avoid being locked in to the default sequences built into their tool, if they provide one.
Warm Up Your Domains and Mailboxes
A new domain that suddenly sends a lot of emails will look suspicious to inbox providers like Google or Microsoft. Warming up your mailbox builds a positive sending history so inbox providers learn to trust you before you send your real campaign emails. Warmups work by having your mailbox send and receive a small volume of emails with other real inboxes, mark them as not spam, and reply. Sequencing tools and mailbox providers have their own private warmup pools and automate this. You could also buy pre-warmed domains if you want to test your cold email channel before scaling it.
I start with a warmup routine of 1–5 emails per day, slowly scaling to 10–15 emails per day by weeks 2 and 3. Then I cap the warmup limit at 10 emails per day and cap my actual sending volume at 20 emails per day, so each mailbox sends 30 emails per day in total. It’s best to do warmups for the first 2 or 3 weeks and then use your mailbox for actual cold outreach.
Set Sending Limits and Rotate Inboxes
The quickest way to burn a domain is to send too many emails. Most people recommend sending around 30 cold emails per mailbox per day. That’s the common guideline, but it isn’t what I do. I send 20 per mailbox per day, and I think 20 to 25 is the safe zone. I’d rather have more mailboxes than squeeze more out of each one. Another tip is to add randomized delays to your sending schedule rather than blasting all the emails together; most sequencing tools have this feature built in.
Skip Open Rate Tracking and Link Tracking
Open rates are tracked by adding a tiny invisible pixel to your email, and clicks are tracked by rewriting your links through a tracking domain. This can reduce deliverability because it’s a small spam trigger, so your emails might land in the promotions tab instead of the main inbox. Open rates also aren’t very reliable. Apple Mail and Gmail preload these pixels automatically, open rates doesn’t mean your prospect opened the email.
So instead of open rates, I measure reply rates:
Reply rate: how many people answer; this indicates that my email lands in their inbox
Positive reply rate: how many of those replies show real interest; this indicates the quality of my prospects
The emails that perform best for me are plain, short, and link-free. Once someone replies positively, I send a scheduling link as a follow-up, after the conversation has started.
Monitoring Deliverability
Inbox placement tests: send test emails to seed inboxes at different providers to see whether you land in the inbox, promotions, or spam. This is useful when you’re testing a new email copy, since email copy can contain spam triggers you’ll want to avoid. Your sequencing or sending tool, or your provider, might have this built in
Bounce rate: a rising bounce rate usually means list quality problems. Keep an eye out for 5.7.1 bounces, which mean the recipient’s spam filter flagged your content or links, or that your domain reputation is now blacklisted
Blacklists: check whether your domains or IPs are listed on any blocklists or spamlists, like Spamhaus
Tools to Consider
I use Primeforge for mailboxes and Instantly for sequencing. Instantly also provides mailboxes, and I use a mix of Instantly and Primeforge mailboxes.
Alternatives worth a look: InboxKit for mailboxes, and Smartlead or EmailBison for sequencing.
That’s pretty much the 101 on infrastructure, but it’s just one part of the entire cold email process. I’ve written other articles on cold email and growth, and you can read more here.